Commonly when schedules are offered, he or she is considering that have 1 day of your own day one really does perhaps not meets with that date whilst from inside the actual records. One such analogy occurs in Harry Potter therefore the Prisoner away single Aracaju in Brazil ladies from Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney relates to 16 Oct because Tuesday, even though sixteen October 1993 was a saturday.
There are even contradictions within the books here. Such as, into the Harry Potter and Goblet out-of Fire, each other step 1 Sep and you will 2 Sep are provided given that Mondays and you can, into the Harry Potter and the Prisoner from Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demonstration is decided for the 20 April, however, mindful parsing of one’s text message demonstrates that this may provides taken place zero after than March.
Together with, into the Harry Potter plus the Cup regarding Flames people say that the Champions was selected toward Monday 30 Oct, however, 30 October is a tuesday into the 1994.
Into the a bankruptcy proceeding regarding Quidditch From the Many years, they claim that the basic Quidditch Globe Glass occured into the 1473. If the title was held all the couple of years, so it issues towards declaration in Goblet of Fire the 1994 World Glass are the fresh new 422nd. In the event that Quidditch From the Ages is right, new 422nd Quidditch Industry Mug manage actually fall-in the year 3161, in case Cup out-of Fire is right, the initial Business Mug ended up being kept for the 306.
Historical issues [ ]
As the collection, with respect to the schedule derived from the brand new Chamber out of Treasures reference, is decided on 1990s, the fresh new show often looks as if it is place in the fresh new late nineties so you can mid-2000s, around concurrent to your guide of one’s books. In Harry Potter plus the Half-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a male pronoun to refer to your “predecessor” of Perfect Minister of your British. Depending on the more than timeline, this should take place in summer time off 1996, if Perfect Minister are John Big, whose quick predecessor is a woman (is why first interviewing Fudge, the book mentions new election, but Major wasn’t initial chose and only grabbed more once Thatcher retired.
You will be able, yet not unrealistic, you to Fudge would-be dealing with a very faraway ancestor, due to the fact Thatcher grabbed work environment prior to Fudge allegedly became Minister to possess Miracle. (Even if it’s possible to consider a situation in which Fudge is delegated because of the Minister for Magic to generally meet to the Perfect Minister as he, Fudge, was at an inferior workplace.) At the same time, the newest identification and you may reputation of the prime Minister represented seems to alot more closely match regarding Tony Blair than out of John Big. A post regarding Day-after-day Send cards that Rowling are close into the next-Chancellor of Exchequer Gordon Brown (often regarded as a competition so you’re able to Blair’s frontrunners of one’s Work Cluster, which succeeded your and you may turned into Finest Minister), which she has been wanting to show Blair’s poor side. If your books was indeed invest connect that have book date from Philosopher’s Stone, upcoming which experience manage occur in 2002 (just after Blair became Perfect Minister).
Yet not, it absolutely was later reported that 22 November is a monday, which it was in 1994
The same problem pertains to Nicolas Flamel, who had been stated as actually 665 during the basic guide, but Nicolas Flamel is actually a real historical figure and you may won’t have reached you to decades up until 1996, in the big date the initial publication is actually blogged. The newest rebuttal because of it is the fact that the time brand new “real” Nicolas Flamel was created cannot correspond with the fresh new Nicolas Flamel from Harry Potter.
A different sort of condition is present of Rubeus Hagrid’s period as Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is implied about show one to Hagrid gotten you to definitely updates contained in this many years regarding their expulsion from university inside 1942. But in you to definitely world away from Harry Potter in addition to Cup out of Fire, Molly Weasley reminisces about Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper apparently overlap that have Molly’s decades at school, it seems unrealistic that she remembers an earlier gamekeeper. Although not, it will be possible one to Hagrid failed to end up being a beneficial gamekeeper instantaneously immediately following are expelled, but instead become as the Ogg’s assistant. This is certainly possible because whenever Harry thinks that he commonly getting expelled to possess flying to the broomstick rather than consent in his first 12 months, the guy wonders when the however be allowed to remain on due to the fact Hagrid’s assistant.
